Adjust Font Size: A A       Guest settings   Register

Looking at Aoki's Case

NPB Tracker Archives

Looking at Aoki's Case

by Patrick Newman (Dec 31, 2011)

After a little discussion about Norichika Aoki on an earlier post, I thought I'd break down the speedy outfielder's case in a little more detail. Here's what I've come up with.

The case for:

  • Was among the best hitters in Japan from 2005-2010, four times hitting .340 or higher (via npb.or.jp/eng)
  • Strong plate discipline mostly survived the new ball
  • Continued to make contact in 2011, career low strikeouts
  • Speed doesn't slump
  • Rangey in the field

The case against:

  • Performance decline in 2011 - from a career-best .358/.435/.509 to a career worst .292/.360/.358 (via Pro Yakyu Data Freak)
  • No power with the new ball; perilous drop from 44 to 18 doubles from 2010 to 2011
  • Weak throwing arm
  • 22.9% of his hits in 2011 were infield singles (according to Pro Yakyu Nuru Data Okiba)
  • In 2011 he hit .382/.452/.520 against Yokohama, padding his stats by bashing Japan's worst pitching staff (also via Pro Yakyu Nuru Data Okiba)
  • "Aoki's plate discipline seems to have regressed" - me, August 5, 2011.

I've flip-flopped on Aoki as a prospect quite a bit this season, though I haven't written much. I was extremely bearish early on, and had kind of written him off as a prospect, then I came around a bit to a more glass-half-full view. Now I'm backing off a bit a again. I think the specific numbers that I've keyed in on paint a rather negative picture.

I think Aoki has enough transferrable skills to be a useful MLB player, but there some real limitations to his game, most notably his lack of power. I still think my Juan Pierre comparison is not such a bad one, with the caveat that Aoki probably won't get enough playing time to rack up 200 hits like Pierre was doing in his prime.


Back to the works of Patrick Newman
Search for Pro Yakyu news and information
Copyright (c) 1995-2024 JapaneseBaseball.com.
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons License.
Some rights reserved.